We’re installing a high-efficiency wood-burning fireplace insert. Should the intake air be drawn from a crawl space surrounded by a concrete perimeter wall or should the wall be cut to draw fresh air?
The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) doesn’t recommend the installation of fresh-air inlets because they don’t always reduce the chance of a combustion back draft and they can be a fire hazard. Under certain conditions, combustion gases and flames can exhaust through the fresh-air inlet instead of up through the chimney. Since the inlets are not designed for this, they don’t provide protection of the surrounding structure and a fire can result.
If you choose a unit that’s specifically designed by the manufacturer for an outside air source and it’s properly and safely installed, you should be okay. It’s possible that a cottager could use an insert with a built-in fresh-air inlet and never have a problem; however, the CMHC’s position is that fresh-air intake inlets don’t offer a major advantage over inserts that draw combustion air from inside, so why bother using one when there’s the possibility of risk?
Related Story How to prep your fireplace for the winter
Related Story Cottage Q&A: Painting a rusty fireplace
Related Story 6 incredible fireplaces